Nutmeg substitutes

The best substitute for nutmeg is mace: 1:1, or very slightly more.

Why it matters. Warm, sweet and slightly woody. A grating goes into bechamel, spinach, custard and spiced bakes to add depth without announcing itself. Overdo it and it turns soapy and medicinal.

Substitutes

Best

mace

1:1, or very slightly more

Mace is the lacy covering of the same seed, so the flavour is genuinely the same, just lighter and more delicate.

freshly grated whole nutmeg

About half a whole nutmeg grates to 1 tsp ground

Far more aromatic than pre-ground, which loses its volatile oils within a few months. Grate it straight into the pan.

allspice

Use about half

Allspice already carries a nutmeg-like note alongside its clove and cinnamon, so it lands closer than cinnamon alone. Stronger, so use less.

pumpkin pie spice

1:1

Nutmeg is one of its main components, so it works well in sweet bakes. The ginger and cinnamon make it wrong for a bechamel or creamed spinach.

cinnamon

Use half the amount

Warm and sweet but far more assertive and a different note entirely. Halve it and taste, especially in a white sauce where nutmeg should be almost invisible.

FAQ

What is the best substitute for nutmeg?

The best substitute for nutmeg is mace: 1:1, or very slightly more. Mace is the lacy covering of the same seed, so the flavour is genuinely the same, just lighter and more delicate.

Why does nutmeg matter in a recipe?

Warm, sweet and slightly woody. A grating goes into bechamel, spinach, custard and spiced bakes to add depth without announcing itself. Overdo it and it turns soapy and medicinal.

Can I use mace instead of nutmeg?

1:1, or very slightly more. Mace is the lacy covering of the same seed, so the flavour is genuinely the same, just lighter and more delicate.

Can I use freshly grated whole nutmeg instead of nutmeg?

About half a whole nutmeg grates to 1 tsp ground. Far more aromatic than pre-ground, which loses its volatile oils within a few months. Grate it straight into the pan.

Can I use allspice instead of nutmeg?

Use about half. Allspice already carries a nutmeg-like note alongside its clove and cinnamon, so it lands closer than cinnamon alone. Stronger, so use less.

Can I use pumpkin pie spice instead of nutmeg?

1:1. Nutmeg is one of its main components, so it works well in sweet bakes. The ginger and cinnamon make it wrong for a bechamel or creamed spinach.

Can I use cinnamon instead of nutmeg?

Use half the amount. Warm and sweet but far more assertive and a different note entirely. Halve it and taste, especially in a white sauce where nutmeg should be almost invisible.

All substitutes · Kitchen conversions

Last updated November 11, 2026.